[HELP-2182] FIWARE.Request.Lab.UAT | 7 Regions tested: "create a VM" scenario. - JIRA

Details

Type: extRequest
Status: Closed
Priority: Major
Resolution: Done
Fix Version/s: 2021
Component/s: FIWARE-LAB-HELP
Labels:
None

Sender Email:
Peter.Muryshkin@iais.fraunhofer.de

Description

Dear FIWARE teams,

in terms of our survey for European Pioneers we have executed a User
Acceptance Test nailed down to the most essential end-user scenario for 7
regions listed below:

I want to be able to get a shell access with a public IP to an instance in
a simple and straightforward way“.

We are available that Terms of Usage are changing soon and ID verfication
will be required to access public IPs, but this is not the issue here.

We have tried today to create an instance in each region with the following
results. (Account name for admins to look up the logs:
christian.bonkowski@iais.fraunhofer.de
<christian.bonkowski@iais.fraunhofer.de> , instance name: test-iais)
Every time we expected that same steps are required to create a VM with a
public IP and shell acccess. We assume also that not every potential
customer with overall intermediate skill level has enough knowledge to
manually configure a network.

Typical error pattern in many cases was, there is a default network which
cannot be used without an error, and custom network usage can also result in
an error.

Region

Public IP allowed

Manual

Details

UAT synopsis

UAT: get IP+VM shell

Lannion

Yes

Manual 12 pages, not very straightforward.

With manual acceptable but not competitive.

PASS

Spain

Yes

No

No Networks/Router, auto-assign of int. IP

Allocation of public IP easy.

PASS

Trento

No

Much trial&error required

Admin skills needed for network

FAIL

Waterford

Yes

No

Manual network config

Undefined error on IP assign.

FAIL

Berlin

No

Manual network config

No public IP available.

FAIL

Pragua

Yes

No

As in Spain, no networks

IP ok. Error on instance creation.

FAIL

Mexico

Yes

No

Own network = no instance

400 error on instance launch.

FAIL

We recommend a to implement a formal quality assurance process based on an
audit so that all regions can implement same must-have common functionality
at least for this one scenario, if possible. Think of McDonlads: you get
identical Cola &BigMac offer everywhere but some regions have got their own
food specials.

Additionally, most successful regions like Spain might want to share their
knowledge with other regions.

Kind regards / viele Grüße & Servus

Peter Muryshkin, M. Sc.

Skype ID: peter_iais

LinkedIn: http://de.linkedin.com/in/muryshkin

----------------------------------------------------------------------------
------

NetMedia / B3-342

Fraunhofer IAIS

Schloss Birlinghoven 1

53754 St. Augustin, Germany

T: +49 2241 14 3413

Email: <Peter.Muryshkin@iais.fraunhofer.de>
Peter.Muryshkin@iais.fraunhofer.de

_______________________________________________
Fiware-lab-help mailing list
Fiware-lab-help@lists.fi-ware.org
https://lists.fi-ware.org/listinfo/fiware-lab-help

[Created via e-mail received from: "Muryshkin, Peter" <Peter.Muryshkin@iais.fraunhofer.de>]

Options
- Sort By Name
- Sort By Date
- Ascending
- Descending
- Download All

Attachments

image001.png

20 kB

27/Feb/15 11:11 AM
prag_vm.png

43 kB

27/Feb/15 11:11 AM

Activity

Ascending order - Click to sort in descending order

Hide

Permalink

Federico Michele Facca added a comment - 19/Feb/15 5:59 PM

Dear Peter,
Thanks for your feedbacks. There is an ongoing effort to make uniform as
much as possible set-up across nodes (in term of naming conventions across
network and access to shared / external networks).

Still, things cannot be identical on each node for several reasons related
to the ability of provide more advanced services to users. Spain uses a
"dumb" service for the network, which has many limitations (sure it's
bullet proof for any unskilled user): e.g. the network that is shared among
all users, which means any vm in spain (regardless the tenant owning it)
can reach transparently any other vm in spain (which is not very safe).

We are going as well to free up resources, thanks to the application of new
policies, that will as well reduce number of errors caused by the fact that
a region is full. We are also establishing automatic functional testing
over each node to be run daily to ensure that nodes behave as supposed.

Regards,
Federico

On Thu, Feb 19, 2015 at 4:12 PM, Muryshkin, Peter <

–
–
Future Internet is closer than you think!
http://www.fiware.org

Official Mirantis partner for OpenStack Training
https://www.create-net.org/community/openstack-training

–
Dr. Federico M. Facca

CREATE-NET
Via alla Cascata 56/D
38123 Povo Trento (Italy)

P +39 0461 312471
M +39 334 6049758
E federico.facca@create-net.org
T @chicco785
W www.create-net.org

_______________________________________________
Fiware-tech-help mailing list
Fiware-tech-help@lists.fi-ware.org
https://lists.fi-ware.org/listinfo/fiware-tech-help

Show

Federico Michele Facca added a comment - 19/Feb/15 5:59 PM Dear Peter, Thanks for your feedbacks. There is an ongoing effort to make uniform as much as possible set-up across nodes (in term of naming conventions across network and access to shared / external networks). Still, things cannot be identical on each node for several reasons related to the ability of provide more advanced services to users. Spain uses a "dumb" service for the network, which has many limitations (sure it's bullet proof for any unskilled user): e.g. the network that is shared among all users, which means any vm in spain (regardless the tenant owning it) can reach transparently any other vm in spain (which is not very safe). We are going as well to free up resources, thanks to the application of new policies, that will as well reduce number of errors caused by the fact that a region is full. We are also establishing automatic functional testing over each node to be run daily to ensure that nodes behave as supposed. Regards, Federico On Thu, Feb 19, 2015 at 4:12 PM, Muryshkin, Peter < – – Future Internet is closer than you think! http://www.fiware.org Official Mirantis partner for OpenStack Training https://www.create-net.org/community/openstack-training – Dr. Federico M. Facca CREATE-NET Via alla Cascata 56/D 38123 Povo Trento (Italy) P +39 0461 312471 M +39 334 6049758 E federico.facca@create-net.org T @chicco785 W www.create-net.org _______________________________________________ Fiware-tech-help mailing list Fiware-tech-help@lists.fi-ware.org https://lists.fi-ware.org/listinfo/fiware-tech-help

Hide

Permalink

Federico Michele Facca added a comment - 19/Feb/15 5:59 PM

Dear Peter,
Thanks for your feedbacks. There is an ongoing effort to make uniform as
much as possible set-up across nodes (in term of naming conventions across
network and access to shared / external networks).

Still, things cannot be identical on each node for several reasons related
to the ability of provide more advanced services to users. Spain uses a
"dumb" service for the network, which has many limitations (sure it's
bullet proof for any unskilled user): e.g. the network that is shared among
all users, which means any vm in spain (regardless the tenant owning it)
can reach transparently any other vm in spain (which is not very safe).

We are going as well to free up resources, thanks to the application of new
policies, that will as well reduce number of errors caused by the fact that
a region is full. We are also establishing automatic functional testing
over each node to be run daily to ensure that nodes behave as supposed.

Regards,
Federico

On Thu, Feb 19, 2015 at 4:12 PM, Muryshkin, Peter <

–
–
Future Internet is closer than you think!
http://www.fiware.org

Official Mirantis partner for OpenStack Training
https://www.create-net.org/community/openstack-training

–
Dr. Federico M. Facca

CREATE-NET
Via alla Cascata 56/D
38123 Povo Trento (Italy)

P +39 0461 312471
M +39 334 6049758
E federico.facca@create-net.org
T @chicco785
W www.create-net.org

_______________________________________________
Fiware-lab-help mailing list
Fiware-lab-help@lists.fi-ware.org
https://lists.fi-ware.org/listinfo/fiware-lab-help

Show

Federico Michele Facca added a comment - 19/Feb/15 5:59 PM Dear Peter, Thanks for your feedbacks. There is an ongoing effort to make uniform as much as possible set-up across nodes (in term of naming conventions across network and access to shared / external networks). Still, things cannot be identical on each node for several reasons related to the ability of provide more advanced services to users. Spain uses a "dumb" service for the network, which has many limitations (sure it's bullet proof for any unskilled user): e.g. the network that is shared among all users, which means any vm in spain (regardless the tenant owning it) can reach transparently any other vm in spain (which is not very safe). We are going as well to free up resources, thanks to the application of new policies, that will as well reduce number of errors caused by the fact that a region is full. We are also establishing automatic functional testing over each node to be run daily to ensure that nodes behave as supposed. Regards, Federico On Thu, Feb 19, 2015 at 4:12 PM, Muryshkin, Peter < – – Future Internet is closer than you think! http://www.fiware.org Official Mirantis partner for OpenStack Training https://www.create-net.org/community/openstack-training – Dr. Federico M. Facca CREATE-NET Via alla Cascata 56/D 38123 Povo Trento (Italy) P +39 0461 312471 M +39 334 6049758 E federico.facca@create-net.org T @chicco785 W www.create-net.org _______________________________________________ Fiware-lab-help mailing list Fiware-lab-help@lists.fi-ware.org https://lists.fi-ware.org/listinfo/fiware-lab-help

Hide

Permalink

FIWARE.Request.Lab.UAT | 7 Regions tested: "create a VM" scenario.

Details

Description

Attachments

Activity

People

Dates

Agile