Uploaded image for project: 'Help-Coaches-Desk'
  1. Help-Coaches-Desk
  2. HELC-439

FIWARE.Request.Coach.FICHe.Re: FW: FIWARE Skype call

    Details

    • Type: extRequest
    • Status: Closed
    • Priority: Major
    • Resolution: Done
    • Component/s: FICHe
    • Labels:
      None

      Description

      Look forward to speak today at 5pm

      Here were the additional questions/topics:

      1. We need to make a financial model for selling a FIWARE based SaaS/PaaS
      but we do not have any pricing information for the FIWARE nodes (compute,
      memory, storage, bandwidth etc). Understand the software components (GEs)
      are open source and royalty free. But what about the Infrastructure
      services? For now we can make estimates on the IaaS production costs based
      on other providers (Amazon, IBM etc) but looking for direction here from
      FIWARE. When I met the London I3H project they didn't seem to know either.

      2. Are there any commercial T+C planned for the FIWARE operations? Service
      level agreements in terms of system uptime, commercial liability,
      indemnification, patent infringement etc

      3, FIWARE Lab - Update of Term and Conditions and new user policies. See
      my other note.

      4. Roadmap on Cosmos GE. We have had hard time to get responses from
      Telefonica and the responses we got didn't provide any roadmap. Can FICHe
      team help with an answer here? We are waiting now for 2 weeks for any
      update. Below is from October 9th 2014 as is the last communication or email
      response we obtained:

      Hi Dave,

      "Sorry for the delay in answering you, I’ve been participating in several
      FIWARE dissemination events.

      Regarding Parquet and Drill, if you have entered the global instance of
      Cosmos you’ll probably have seen the Hadoop version we are currently using
      is pretty old. In addition, it is quite limited in resources. It was
      initially addressed to hackathonists and newbies trying to get an easy
      approach to the Hadoop ecosystem, but not for more advanced usage. We are
      working on deploying a, let’s say, more “professional” Big Data platform,
      and I hope it is ready before the end of the year. In the meantime, I’ll try
      to stress the current deployment and I’ll study if any of those technologies
      can be exposed to the FILAB users, but as you are pointing, Drill requires
      recent Hadoop APIs.

      Regards,
      Francisco"

      on 18/2/15 12:11 PM, Franck Le Gall <franck.le-gall@eglobalmark.com> wrote:

      > Dear Dave,
      >
      > Would you have availabilities on Thursday between 1pm and 3pm ?
      >
      > Do you have questions beyond the filab related one ?
      >
      > Kind regards
      > Franck
      >
      > ----Message d'origine----
      > De : fiware-fiche-coaching-bounces@lists.fi-ware.org
      > fiware-fiche-coaching-bounces@lists.fi-ware.org De la part de
      Paul
      > Pelsmaeker - Digitalezorg.nl
      > Envoyé : lundi 16 février 2015 15:52
      > À : fiware-fiche-coaching@lists.fi-ware.org
      > Objet : [Fiware-fiche-coaching] FW: FIWARE Skype call
      >
      > Hi,
      >
      > Find attached a request from one of our participants to have a quick Skype
      > call (max 15 min) with one of the FIWARE coached as discussed with Franck.
      >
      > Please contact them through their email address:
      dave.watson@trendalyze.com
      >
      > BR
      >
      > Paul
      > FICHe
      >
      > ----Oorspronkelijk bericht----
      > Van: "Dave" dave.watson@trendalyze.com
      > Aan: fiche@digitalezorg.nl
      > Onderwerp: FIWARE Skype call
      >
      > I would like to schedule the one on one Skype call regarding FIWARE.
      >
      > ------ Forwarded Message
      >> From: Paul Pelsmaeker ✓ via f6s.com <donotreply@f6s.com>
      >> Date: Monday, February 9, 2015 12:50 PM
      >> To: dave.watson@trendalyze.com
      >> Subject: Paul Pelsmaeker ✓ has posted on FICHe Private Group
      >>
      >>
      > ------ End of Forwarded Message
      >
      >
      >
      _______________________________________________
      Fiware-fiche-coaching mailing list
      Fiware-fiche-coaching@lists.fi-ware.org
      https://lists.fi-ware.org/listinfo/fiware-fiche-coaching

      [Created via e-mail received from: =?utf-8?q?=22Dave=22?= <dave.watson@trendalyze.com>]

        Activity

        Hide
        fw.ext.user FW External User added a comment -

        Got your SMS. Email is fine if we can get answers in next 1-2 days

        Just to clarify terms as I think it might have been confusing in email

        When I said node I mean a Linux server instance with a public IP address
        (what we could call node in Hadoop/ZooKeeper cluster)

        I didn't mean a node in the way FIWARE defines a geographic hub/data centre

        Presently we can not bring up a 4 node cluster of our own through the FI
        Lab as we need 4 public IP.

        On Fri, Feb 20, 2015 at 10:38 AM, "Dave" <dave.watson@trendalyze.com> wrote:

        > Look forward to speak today at 5pm
        >
        > Here were the additional questions/topics:
        >
        > 1. We need to make a financial model for selling a FIWARE based SaaS/PaaS
        > but we do not have any pricing information for the FIWARE nodes (compute,
        > memory, storage, bandwidth etc). Understand the software components (GEs)
        > are open source and royalty free. But what about the Infrastructure
        > services? For now we can make estimates on the IaaS production costs based
        > on other providers (Amazon, IBM etc) but looking for direction here from
        > FIWARE. When I met the London I3H project they didn't seem to know either.
        >
        > 2. Are there any commercial T+C planned for the FIWARE operations? Service
        > level agreements in terms of system uptime, commercial liability,
        > indemnification, patent infringement etc
        >
        > 3, FIWARE Lab - Update of Term and Conditions and new user policies. See
        > my other note.
        >
        > 4. Roadmap on Cosmos GE. We have had hard time to get responses from
        > Telefonica and the responses we got didn't provide any roadmap. Can FICHe
        > team help with an answer here? We are waiting now for 2 weeks for any
        > update. Below is from October 9th 2014 as is the last communication or
        > email
        > response we obtained:
        >
        > Hi Dave,
        >
        > "Sorry for the delay in answering you, I’ve been participating in several
        > FIWARE dissemination events.
        >
        > Regarding Parquet and Drill, if you have entered the global instance of
        > Cosmos you’ll probably have seen the Hadoop version we are currently using
        > is pretty old. In addition, it is quite limited in resources. It was
        > initially addressed to hackathonists and newbies trying to get an easy
        > approach to the Hadoop ecosystem, but not for more advanced usage. We are
        > working on deploying a, let’s say, more “professional” Big Data platform,
        > and I hope it is ready before the end of the year. In the meantime, I’ll
        > try
        > to stress the current deployment and I’ll study if any of those
        > technologies
        > can be exposed to the FILAB users, but as you are pointing, Drill requires
        > recent Hadoop APIs.
        >
        > Regards,
        > Francisco"
        >
        >
        >
        > on 18/2/15 12:11 PM, Franck Le Gall <franck.le-gall@eglobalmark.com>
        > wrote:
        >
        > > Dear Dave,
        > >
        > > Would you have availabilities on Thursday between 1pm and 3pm ?
        > >
        > > Do you have questions beyond the filab related one ?
        > >
        > > Kind regards
        > > Franck
        > >
        > > ----Message d'origine----
        > > De : fiware-fiche-coaching-bounces@lists.fi-ware.org
        > > fiware-fiche-coaching-bounces@lists.fi-ware.org De la part de
        > Paul
        > > Pelsmaeker - Digitalezorg.nl
        > > Envoyé : lundi 16 février 2015 15:52
        > > À : fiware-fiche-coaching@lists.fi-ware.org
        > > Objet : [Fiware-fiche-coaching] FW: FIWARE Skype call
        > >
        > > Hi,
        > >
        > > Find attached a request from one of our participants to have a quick
        > Skype
        > > call (max 15 min) with one of the FIWARE coached as discussed with
        > Franck.
        > >
        > > Please contact them through their email address:
        > dave.watson@trendalyze.com
        > >
        > > BR
        > >
        > > Paul
        > > FICHe
        > >
        > > ----Oorspronkelijk bericht----
        > > Van: "Dave" dave.watson@trendalyze.com
        > > Aan: fiche@digitalezorg.nl
        > > Onderwerp: FIWARE Skype call
        > >
        > > I would like to schedule the one on one Skype call regarding FIWARE.
        > >
        > > ------ Forwarded Message
        > >> From: Paul Pelsmaeker ✓ via f6s.com <donotreply@f6s.com>
        > >> Date: Monday, February 9, 2015 12:50 PM
        > >> To: dave.watson@trendalyze.com
        > >> Subject: Paul Pelsmaeker ✓ has posted on FICHe Private Group
        > >>
        > >>
        > > ------ End of Forwarded Message
        > >
        > >
        > >
        >

        Dave Watson
        +447741675325 (UK)
        +17862642749 (USA)

        _______________________________________________
        Fiware-fiche-coaching mailing list
        Fiware-fiche-coaching@lists.fi-ware.org
        https://lists.fi-ware.org/listinfo/fiware-fiche-coaching

        Show
        fw.ext.user FW External User added a comment - Got your SMS. Email is fine if we can get answers in next 1-2 days Just to clarify terms as I think it might have been confusing in email When I said node I mean a Linux server instance with a public IP address (what we could call node in Hadoop/ZooKeeper cluster) I didn't mean a node in the way FIWARE defines a geographic hub/data centre Presently we can not bring up a 4 node cluster of our own through the FI Lab as we need 4 public IP. On Fri, Feb 20, 2015 at 10:38 AM, "Dave" <dave.watson@trendalyze.com> wrote: > Look forward to speak today at 5pm > > Here were the additional questions/topics: > > 1. We need to make a financial model for selling a FIWARE based SaaS/PaaS > but we do not have any pricing information for the FIWARE nodes (compute, > memory, storage, bandwidth etc). Understand the software components (GEs) > are open source and royalty free. But what about the Infrastructure > services? For now we can make estimates on the IaaS production costs based > on other providers (Amazon, IBM etc) but looking for direction here from > FIWARE. When I met the London I3H project they didn't seem to know either. > > 2. Are there any commercial T+C planned for the FIWARE operations? Service > level agreements in terms of system uptime, commercial liability, > indemnification, patent infringement etc > > 3, FIWARE Lab - Update of Term and Conditions and new user policies. See > my other note. > > 4. Roadmap on Cosmos GE. We have had hard time to get responses from > Telefonica and the responses we got didn't provide any roadmap. Can FICHe > team help with an answer here? We are waiting now for 2 weeks for any > update. Below is from October 9th 2014 as is the last communication or > email > response we obtained: > > Hi Dave, > > "Sorry for the delay in answering you, I’ve been participating in several > FIWARE dissemination events. > > Regarding Parquet and Drill, if you have entered the global instance of > Cosmos you’ll probably have seen the Hadoop version we are currently using > is pretty old. In addition, it is quite limited in resources. It was > initially addressed to hackathonists and newbies trying to get an easy > approach to the Hadoop ecosystem, but not for more advanced usage. We are > working on deploying a, let’s say, more “professional” Big Data platform, > and I hope it is ready before the end of the year. In the meantime, I’ll > try > to stress the current deployment and I’ll study if any of those > technologies > can be exposed to the FILAB users, but as you are pointing, Drill requires > recent Hadoop APIs. > > Regards, > Francisco" > > > > on 18/2/15 12:11 PM, Franck Le Gall <franck.le-gall@eglobalmark.com> > wrote: > > > Dear Dave, > > > > Would you have availabilities on Thursday between 1pm and 3pm ? > > > > Do you have questions beyond the filab related one ? > > > > Kind regards > > Franck > > > > ---- Message d'origine ---- > > De : fiware-fiche-coaching-bounces@lists.fi-ware.org > > fiware-fiche-coaching-bounces@lists.fi-ware.org De la part de > Paul > > Pelsmaeker - Digitalezorg.nl > > Envoyé : lundi 16 février 2015 15:52 > > À : fiware-fiche-coaching@lists.fi-ware.org > > Objet : [Fiware-fiche-coaching] FW: FIWARE Skype call > > > > Hi, > > > > Find attached a request from one of our participants to have a quick > Skype > > call (max 15 min) with one of the FIWARE coached as discussed with > Franck. > > > > Please contact them through their email address: > dave.watson@trendalyze.com > > > > BR > > > > Paul > > FICHe > > > > ---- Oorspronkelijk bericht ---- > > Van: "Dave" dave.watson@trendalyze.com > > Aan: fiche@digitalezorg.nl > > Onderwerp: FIWARE Skype call > > > > I would like to schedule the one on one Skype call regarding FIWARE. > > > > ------ Forwarded Message > >> From: Paul Pelsmaeker ✓ via f6s.com <donotreply@f6s.com> > >> Date: Monday, February 9, 2015 12:50 PM > >> To: dave.watson@trendalyze.com > >> Subject: Paul Pelsmaeker ✓ has posted on FICHe Private Group > >> > >> > > ------ End of Forwarded Message > > > > > > > – Dave Watson +447741675325 (UK) +17862642749 (USA) _______________________________________________ Fiware-fiche-coaching mailing list Fiware-fiche-coaching@lists.fi-ware.org https://lists.fi-ware.org/listinfo/fiware-fiche-coaching
        Hide
        flegall Franck Le Gall added a comment -

        Here it is :

        · We need to make a financial model for selling a FIWARE based SaaS/PaaS but we do not have any pricing information for the FIWARE nodes (compute, memory, storage, bandwidth etc). Understand the software components (GEs) are open source and royalty free. But what about the Infrastructure services? For now we can make estimates on the IaaS production costs based on other providers (Amazon, IBM etc) but looking for direction here from FIWARE. When I met the London I3H project they didn't seem to know either.

        FIWARE lab is today intended for test & development purpose only. You should not go in production with it. I am not aware of any detailed plan for a production grade fiware environment. However, the sustainability plan for the fiware community is now being refined: an announcement to support the GEs will be made early March at mwc Barcelone. We expect that commercial offers for the cloud hosting will follow, either from the community, either from individual organisations, or both, but nothing is set yet.

        · Are there any commercial T+C planned for the FIWARE operations? Service level agreements in terms of system uptime, commercial liability, indemnification, patent infringement etc

        Covered above I think

        · FIWARE Lab - Update of Term and Conditions and new user policies. See my other note.

        See first point: not yet intended for production

        · Roadmap on Cosmos GE. We have had hard time to get responses from Telefonica and the responses we got didn't provide any roadmap. Can FICHe team help with an answer here? We are waiting now for 2 weeks for any update.

        I am investigating this

        · We need to set-up 4 nodes in the hadoop sense, meaning 4 linux instances each with a different public IP.

        The availability of public IPs is indeed an issue currently and the new policy is expected to solve this. However, could this be made with 1 public + 3 private adresses ? (see http://stackoverflow.com/questions/25135183/hadoop-binding-multiple-ip-addresses-to-a-cluster-namenode)

        Come back to me as needed

        _______________________________________________
        Fiware-fiche-coaching mailing list
        Fiware-fiche-coaching@lists.fi-ware.org
        https://lists.fi-ware.org/listinfo/fiware-fiche-coaching

        Show
        flegall Franck Le Gall added a comment - Here it is : · We need to make a financial model for selling a FIWARE based SaaS/PaaS but we do not have any pricing information for the FIWARE nodes (compute, memory, storage, bandwidth etc). Understand the software components (GEs) are open source and royalty free. But what about the Infrastructure services? For now we can make estimates on the IaaS production costs based on other providers (Amazon, IBM etc) but looking for direction here from FIWARE. When I met the London I3H project they didn't seem to know either. FIWARE lab is today intended for test & development purpose only. You should not go in production with it. I am not aware of any detailed plan for a production grade fiware environment. However, the sustainability plan for the fiware community is now being refined: an announcement to support the GEs will be made early March at mwc Barcelone. We expect that commercial offers for the cloud hosting will follow, either from the community, either from individual organisations, or both, but nothing is set yet. · Are there any commercial T+C planned for the FIWARE operations? Service level agreements in terms of system uptime, commercial liability, indemnification, patent infringement etc Covered above I think · FIWARE Lab - Update of Term and Conditions and new user policies. See my other note. See first point: not yet intended for production · Roadmap on Cosmos GE. We have had hard time to get responses from Telefonica and the responses we got didn't provide any roadmap. Can FICHe team help with an answer here? We are waiting now for 2 weeks for any update. I am investigating this · We need to set-up 4 nodes in the hadoop sense, meaning 4 linux instances each with a different public IP. The availability of public IPs is indeed an issue currently and the new policy is expected to solve this. However, could this be made with 1 public + 3 private adresses ? (see http://stackoverflow.com/questions/25135183/hadoop-binding-multiple-ip-addresses-to-a-cluster-namenode ) Come back to me as needed _______________________________________________ Fiware-fiche-coaching mailing list Fiware-fiche-coaching@lists.fi-ware.org https://lists.fi-ware.org/listinfo/fiware-fiche-coaching

          People

          • Assignee:
            flegall Franck Le Gall
            Reporter:
            fw.ext.user FW External User
          • Votes:
            0 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            2 Start watching this issue

            Dates

            • Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved: