Comment by einramhof@atb-bremen.de :

Hi,

just to let you know that I've received both of your messages.
Since the team that had raised the issue was also in CC (and I have also forwarded your messages again to them), they should have received those messages, too.
I have not got any response from the team, and as it seems, neither have you.
If that's the case, you can close the ticket - since Federico has already answered on StackOverflow, there's still a means to pick the issue up, if needed.

Thanks for your help and kind regards,
Peter.

----Ursprüngliche Nachricht----
Von: Help-Coaches-Desk coaches-help-desk-jira@fi-ware.org
Gesendet: Mittwoch, 3. August 2016 11:52
An: omer.ozdemir@atos.net; Peter Einramhof <einramhof@atb-bremen.de>
Cc: aalonsog@dit.upm.es; r.puthli@itude.com; fiware-finish-coaching@lists.fiware.org
Betreff: [FIWARE-JIRA] (HELC-1430) [Fiware-finish-coaching] WG: [FInish-Technology] KeyRock status after FINISH ends

>From FIWARE JIRA - Coaches Help Desk ----

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Comments:

ilknur chulani - Today 12:51 PM
------------------
Dear Peter and Robin,

We will close this ticket if we do not hear back from you in the next few days.

Kind regards,

ilknur

ilknur chulani - 27/Jul/16 3:40 PM
------------------
Dear Peter and Robin,

Federico Alvarez has responded to your question in the Stackoverflow posting. Does it solve your problem:

https://stackoverflow.com/questions/37094473/fiware-keyrock-scim-api-bug-check-allowed-to-get-and-assign-got-an-unexpecte

Best regards,

ilknur

FW External User - 14/Jul/16 11:11 AM
------------------
Comment by einramhof@atb-bremen.de :

Dear Omer, dear Alvaro,

thanks a lot for taking care of this issue!
Very much appreciated.

Kind regards,
Peter.

Von: Ozdemir, Omer Faruk omer.ozdemir@atos.net
Gesendet: Donnerstag, 14. Juli 2016 09:57
An: Peter Einramhof <einramhof@atb-bremen.de>; Chulani, Ilknur <ilknur.chulani@atos.net>
Cc: Fiware-finish-coaching@lists.fiware.org; Robin Puthli (r.puthli@itude.com) <r.puthli@itude.com>; Karaboga, Burak <burak.karaboga@atos.net>; Álvaro Alonso <aalonsog@dit.upm.es>
Betreff: RE: [Fiware-finish-coaching] WG: [FInish-Technology] KeyRock status after FINISH ends

Dear Peter, good morning,

I've contacted with Alvaro Alonso and he said that they are already working on this issue, you will hear from them in a short time hopefully.

Kind regards
Omer

Ozdemir, Omer Faruk - 14/Jul/16 10:59 AM
------------------

Dear Peter, good morning,

I've contacted with Alvaro Alonso and he said that they are already working on this issue, you will hear from them in a short time hopefully.

Kind regards
Omer

Ozdemir, Omer Faruk - 07/Jul/16 2:54 PM
------------------

Dear Peter,

Ilknur is now on holidays, me and my collegue Burak are here to help you.

Could you please share the Jira ticket number/link(if there has been created once before)?
Or there is only stackoverflow page for this issue?

We will take necessary actions one you share the details with us..

Kind regards
Omer

------------------------
Issue id: HELC-1430
Description:
Dear Ilknur,

one of our teams had reported an issue with KeyRock some months ago – while there had been some contact with the developer(s) of the GE, and the response that they are working on it (May 23rd), there hasn’t been any progress/solution of this issue until today – see email below.

Is there a way to boost the priority of the issue and get the seemingly stopped wheels in motion again?

Kind regards,
Peter on behalf of FInish.

Von: finish-technology-bounces@atb-bremen.de finish-technology-bounces@atb-bremen.de Im Auftrag von Robin Puthli
Gesendet: Dienstag, 5. Juli 2016 15:04
An: FInish-technology@finish-project.eu
Cc: Cor Verdouw <cor.verdouw@wur.nl>
Betreff: [FInish-Technology] KeyRock status after FINISH ends

Dear FINISH technology readers,

I am increasingly concerned about the KeyRock Generic Enabler.
We have an outstanding issue which was not essential for our FINISH project, but which will block future development:
https://stackoverflow.com/questions/37094473/fiware-keyrock-scim-api-bug-check-allowed-to-get-and-assign-got-an-unexpecte

The issue has been open for two months and the developer does not seem interested in fixing it. The code on Github seems to have come to a complete halt after May 2016.
[cid:image001.png@01D1D6D3.ACEDBC80]

I have spoken to a bunch of FIWARE projects and have not met one that has adopted KeyRock on their own infrastructure. So i am hoping that we are not the only company using it?
At the present rate of maintenance on the KeyRock IDM we will likely be forced to abandon it and substitute with a different identity management product or write our own. Neither options are very attractive.

Is there anything you can do to bump this issue up in priority?
Is there anything you can do to salvage this GE, which otherwise seems doomed?

Best regards,
Robin Puthli

Met vriendelijke groet,

Robin Puthli
Directeur

[cid:DBE2B82F-A4DD-42A8-8906-E4CEBC37BAC6]
Lageweg 2
3703 CA Zeist
■ mob +31(0) 6 21 88 22 86
■ tel direct +31(0)30 692 60 04
■ tel receptie +31(0)30 699 70 20
■ mail r.puthli@itude.com<r.puthli@itude.com>
■ google.com/+RobinPuthli<http://google.com/+RobinPuthli>
■ skype: robin.puthli
■ linkedIn:nl.linkedin.com/in/puthli/<http://nl.linkedin.com/in/puthli/>

www.itude.com<http://www.itude.com/> ■ K.v.K. 30146090

Dear Peter and Robin,

We will close this ticket if we do not hear back from you in the next few days.

Kind regards,

ilknur

Dear Peter and Robin,

Federico Alvarez has responded to your question in the Stackoverflow posting. Does it solve your problem:

https://stackoverflow.com/questions/37094473/fiware-keyrock-scim-api-bug-check-allowed-to-get-and-assign-got-an-unexpecte

Best regards,

ilknur

Comment by einramhof@atb-bremen.de :

Dear Omer, dear Alvaro,

thanks a lot for taking care of this issue!
Very much appreciated.

Kind regards,
Peter.

Von: Ozdemir, Omer Faruk omer.ozdemir@atos.net
Gesendet: Donnerstag, 14. Juli 2016 09:57
An: Peter Einramhof <einramhof@atb-bremen.de>; Chulani, Ilknur <ilknur.chulani@atos.net>
Cc: Fiware-finish-coaching@lists.fiware.org; Robin Puthli (r.puthli@itude.com) <r.puthli@itude.com>; Karaboga, Burak <burak.karaboga@atos.net>; Álvaro Alonso <aalonsog@dit.upm.es>
Betreff: RE: [Fiware-finish-coaching] WG: [FInish-Technology] KeyRock status after FINISH ends

Dear Peter, good morning,

I've contacted with Alvaro Alonso and he said that they are already working on this issue, you will hear from them in a short time hopefully.

Kind regards
Omer

Dear Peter, good morning,

I've contacted with Alvaro Alonso and he said that they are already working on this issue, you will hear from them in a short time hopefully.

Kind regards
Omer

Dear Peter,

Ilknur is now on holidays, me and my collegue Burak are here to help you.

Could you please share the Jira ticket number/link(if there has been created once before)?
Or there is only stackoverflow page for this issue?

We will take necessary actions one you share the details with us..

Kind regards
Omer